Top 10 Home Warranty Company in Indianapolis, IN

Updated March 2026 · Based on licensing, reviews & response time

Quick Answer

Top: Residential Warranty Services (3.1), Heather MacLaughlin, Choice Home Warranty (3), ServicePlus Home Warranty (3.1)

1

Residential Warranty Services

698 Pro-Med Ln, Carmel, IN 46032, USA
★★★☆☆ 3.1 (926 reviews)
Licensed & InsuredTop Rated
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (800) 544-8156
2

Heather MacLaughlin, Choice Home Warranty

8500 Keystone Crossing Suite 170, Indianapolis, IN 46240, USA
★★★☆☆ 3 (15 reviews)
Licensed & InsuredTop Rated
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (317) 956-9437
3

ServicePlus Home Warranty

1808 Avenue P Suite 101, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA
★★★☆☆ 3.1 (3,010 reviews)
Licensed & InsuredTop Rated
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (800) 545-0402
4

Select Home Warranty

1000 Wyckoff Ave, Mahwah, NJ 07430, USA
★★½☆☆ 2.6 (595 reviews)
Licensed & Insured
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (855) 267-3532
5

First American Home Warranty

1244 Apollo Way, Santa Rosa, CA 95407, USA
★★★☆☆ 3 (4,824 reviews)
Licensed & Insured
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (800) 992-3400
6

The Appliance Guys

9465 Counselors Row, Indianapolis, IN 46240, USA
★★★★☆ 4.3 (1,207 reviews)
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (317) 536-2400
7

West Shore Home

7531 Miles Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46231, USA
★★★★½ 4.8 (640 reviews)
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (463) 223-8349
8

RV Warranty and RV Extended Warranty

8888 Keystone Crossing, Indianapolis, IN 46240, USA
★☆☆☆☆ 1 (1 reviews)
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (888) 299-9888
9

HomeSense

2201 E 46th St Suite 200, Indianapolis, IN 46205, USA
★★★★½ 4.9 (637 reviews)
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (317) 203-8809
10

Arbor Homes & Design Studio Indianapolis

9225 Harrison Park Ct, Indianapolis, IN 46216, USA
★★★★☆ 4 (427 reviews)
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (317) 674-7600

How We Ranked These Indianapolis Pros

Our rankings are based on a weighted evaluation of five key factors:

  1. Licensing & Insurance — All listed businesses hold active state licenses verified through official databases.
  2. Customer Reviews — We aggregate ratings from Google, Yelp, and the BBB, weighting recency and review volume.
  3. Response Time — Companies offering same-day or 24/7 emergency service score higher.
  4. Pricing Transparency — Businesses who offer flat-rate pricing or free estimates rank above those with opaque billing.
  5. Experience & Longevity — Years serving the Indianapolis market and breadth of services factor into overall reliability.

Rankings are reviewed quarterly. Have a correction? Contact us.

Frequently Asked Questions

Best home warranty in Indianapolis?

Top rated: Residential Warranty Services (3.1), Heather MacLaughlin, Choice Home Warranty (3), ServicePlus Home Warranty (3.1).

Common Home Warranty Questions

Other Services in Indianapolis, IN

Appliance RepairAsphaltCarpenterCarpet CleaningCleaning ServiceConcreteDemolitionDrywallElectricianFencingFire DamageFlooring