Best Home Warranty Companies in Indianapolis, IN

Updated March 2026 · Based on licensing, reviews & response time

How We Identified the Best Home Warranty in Indianapolis, IN

Our "best" ranking goes beyond star ratings. We evaluated home warranty companies in Indianapolis, IN on licensing, insurance, complaint history, response time, and pricing transparency to surface the truly top-tier options.

💡 Quick Tips:
  • Verify the company's license number on your state's contractor board website
  • Read recent reviews specifically from Indianapolis, IN customers, not just overall ratings
  • Ask about warranties on both parts and labor before signing a contract
1

Residential Warranty Services

698 Pro-Med Ln, Carmel, IN 46032, USA
★★★☆☆ 3.1 (926 reviews)
Licensed & InsuredTop Rated
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (800) 544-8156
2

Heather MacLaughlin, Choice Home Warranty

8500 Keystone Crossing Suite 170, Indianapolis, IN 46240, USA
★★★☆☆ 3 (15 reviews)
Licensed & InsuredTop Rated
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (317) 956-9437
3

ServicePlus Home Warranty

1808 Avenue P Suite 101, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA
★★★☆☆ 3.1 (3,010 reviews)
Licensed & InsuredTop Rated
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (800) 545-0402
4

Select Home Warranty

1000 Wyckoff Ave, Mahwah, NJ 07430, USA
★★½☆☆ 2.6 (595 reviews)
Licensed & Insured
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (855) 267-3532
5

First American Home Warranty

1244 Apollo Way, Santa Rosa, CA 95407, USA
★★★☆☆ 3 (4,824 reviews)
Licensed & Insured
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (800) 992-3400
6

The Appliance Guys

9465 Counselors Row, Indianapolis, IN 46240, USA
★★★★☆ 4.3 (1,207 reviews)
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (317) 536-2400
7

West Shore Home

7531 Miles Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46231, USA
★★★★½ 4.8 (640 reviews)
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (463) 223-8349
8

RV Warranty and RV Extended Warranty

8888 Keystone Crossing, Indianapolis, IN 46240, USA
★☆☆☆☆ 1 (1 reviews)
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (888) 299-9888
9

HomeSense

2201 E 46th St Suite 200, Indianapolis, IN 46205, USA
★★★★½ 4.9 (637 reviews)
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (317) 203-8809
10

Arbor Homes & Design Studio Indianapolis

9225 Harrison Park Ct, Indianapolis, IN 46216, USA
★★★★☆ 4 (427 reviews)
Services: Home Warranty
Indianapolis, IN (317) 674-7600

How We Ranked These Indianapolis Pros

Our rankings are based on a weighted evaluation of five key factors:

  1. Licensing & Insurance — All listed businesses hold active state licenses verified through official databases.
  2. Customer Reviews — We aggregate ratings from Google, Yelp, and the BBB, weighting recency and review volume.
  3. Response Time — Companies offering same-day or 24/7 emergency service score higher.
  4. Pricing Transparency — Businesses who offer flat-rate pricing or free estimates rank above those with opaque billing.
  5. Experience & Longevity — Years serving the Indianapolis market and breadth of services factor into overall reliability.

Rankings are reviewed quarterly. Have a correction? Contact us.

Common Best Home Warranty Questions

Other Services in Indianapolis, IN

Appliance RepairAsphaltCarpenterCarpet CleaningCleaning ServiceConcreteDemolitionDrywallElectricianFencingFire DamageFlooring