Stop and call a pro now if
- The smell is in the air near the water heater, stove or furnace rather than in the water. Treat it as a gas leak: leave the house without switching anything on or off, and call your gas utility or 911 from outside.
- Your carbon monoxide alarm sounds. Get everyone out and call 911.
Likely causes
-
Sulfate reacting with the magnesium anode
NDSU Extension explains that sulfate in the water reacts with the magnesium anode rod that protects the tank, producing hydrogen sulfide gas. MDH adds that sulfur bacteria in the warm tank are part of the problem. That is why only the hot side smells.
-
Sulfur bacteria in the tank
The Minnesota Department of Health notes that a water heater creates a warm environment where sulfur bacteria can live and produce the gas.
-
Sulfur in the water supply
If the cold water smells too, the source is the well or the water supply, not the heater. MDH suggests smelling the hot and cold taps after the water has sat unused for a few hours.
-
Bacteria in a softener or treatment system
MDH notes the bacteria can also live in a water softener or other treatment device. In that case, the installer or manufacturer should disinfect it.
What you can safely check
These checks tell you where the smell comes from. The fixes inside the tank are plumber work.
-
Smell hot and cold separately
Run cold water at a tap, then hot water at the same tap, after the water has sat for a few hours. Hot only points to the heater. Both points to the water supply.
-
Check whether it fades with use
A smell that is strongest first thing in the morning or after a trip, then fades, fits the heater as the source.
-
Test a private well
If the cold water smells, have the well water tested for sulfate, iron and bacteria before treating the heater.
-
Note the heater's age and any treatment equipment
Write down the age on the label and whether you have a water softener or other treatment system. The plumber will ask.
Avoid these
- Pulling the anode rod out and leaving it out. MDH warns this may significantly shorten the heater's life.
- Turning the thermostat up high to kill bacteria yourself. MDH cautions that raising the temperature can be dangerous, and the setting must come back down afterward to prevent scalding.
- Putting chlorine bleach or other chemicals into the tank yourself.
When to call a pro
- The smell comes only from the hot water and doesn't fade.
- You want the anode rod replaced with an aluminum or aluminum/zinc one.
- The tank needs to be flushed and disinfected.
- Both hot and cold water smell, which calls for a well or water treatment specialist.
NDSU and MDH both point to replacing the magnesium anode with an aluminum one as the usual fix. MDH adds that chlorine disinfection of the tank can help, but the smell may come back. Ask the plumber which they recommend for your water.
Typical repair costs
National ranges for parts and labor from HomeGuide.
Frequently asked questions
Is it safe to shower in hot water that smells like rotten eggs?
MDH says that in most cases the rotten-egg smell has nothing to do with the sanitary quality of the water. A strong smell in the air near a gas appliance is different and should be treated as a gas leak.
Why does only my hot water smell?
Sulfate in the water, helped by sulfur bacteria, reacts with the magnesium anode inside the tank and makes hydrogen sulfide. The cold water never touches the anode, so it doesn't smell.
Will flushing the water heater fix the smell?
It can help for a while, but the smell usually returns unless the anode is changed or the tank is disinfected.
Can I just remove the anode rod?
No. The anode protects the tank from corrosion. MDH warns that removing it may significantly shorten the heater's life. Replace it with an aluminum or aluminum/zinc anode instead.
Sources
- Rotten egg odor only from the hot water tap , NDSU Extension
- Why Does My Water Smell Like Rotten Eggs? Hydrogen Sulfide and Sulfur Bacteria in Well Water , Minnesota Department of Health
- Water Heater Repair Cost , HomeGuide