Water Heater Making Noise? What Each Sound Means and Costs

Quiet ticking, humming and gurgling are normal water heater sounds. Popping and rumbling usually mean sediment in the tank, and a flush often fixes it. Hissing or sizzling can mean water on the burner or a leak, and that should be checked soon.

Stop and call a pro now if

  • You smell gas near a gas water heater. Leave and call your gas utility or 911 from outside.
  • The temperature and pressure (T&P) relief valve is releasing water or steam, or the hot water is scalding. Stay clear of the discharge pipe, turn the heater off (gas to Off, or the breaker for electric) and call a plumber.
  • Water is leaking from the tank itself, or you hear hissing or sizzling with water pooling. Turn off power or gas and the cold supply valve, and call a plumber.

Likely causes

  • Popping or rumbling: sediment

    Minerals settle at the bottom of a tank heater. Water trapped under the layer boils into steam bubbles that pop as they escape. Hard water makes it worse.

  • Crackling: sediment or anode by-products

    Crackling usually has the same sediment cause. On some tanks, an aluminum anode rod reacting with the water leaves jelly-like beads that you see when flushing.

  • Hissing or sizzling: water meeting heat

    On a gas heater, water dripping onto the hot burner sizzles, whether from condensation or a leak. On an electric heater, a leaking element gasket can do the same. Brief sizzling on a gas heater right after a lot of hot water is used is often condensation and stops as the tank heats. Sizzling that continues, or comes with water on the floor, is a leak.

  • Dripping relief valve or knocking: thermal expansion

    In a closed system, where a check valve or pressure-reducing valve stops water from flowing back to the main, heated water has nowhere to expand. Pressure rises, the T&P valve drips and pipes can knock. An expansion tank fixes it.

  • Screeching or whistling: restricted flow or pressure

    A partly closed inlet or outlet valve, a faulty T&P valve, sediment, or high internal pressure can make water whistle through a narrow opening.

  • Banging or knocking: water hammer

    Often the plumbing rather than the heater. Water that stops suddenly when a valve closes slams the pipes. High water pressure and loose pipes make it worse.

  • Ticking, humming or gurgling: normal

    Pipes and heat traps tick as they expand and cool. Electric elements hum while heating. Gurgling after heavy use is water moving. All are normal if quiet and brief.

What you can safely check

Identify the sound and when it happens: while heating, after someone runs water, or all the time. That tells you most of what you need to know.

  1. Look for water

    Check the floor around the base, the fittings on top, and the end of the T&P discharge pipe. Water anywhere changes this from a noise to a leak.

  2. Make sure the valves are fully open

    For screeching or whistling, check that the cold inlet and hot outlet valves are fully open.

  3. Flush the tank

    For popping, rumbling or crackling, A.O. Smith and Rheem both recommend flushing at least once a year. Turn the heater off (gas to Off, or the breaker off for electric), close the cold supply and let the water cool. Run a hose from the drain valve to a floor drain or outside, open a hot faucet in the house to let air in, and drain. Briefly open the cold supply to stir and rinse out sediment. Then close the drain, open the cold supply, and keep the hot faucet open until water runs from it steadily with no sputtering. Only then turn the heat back on, following the relighting steps in the manual for gas. An electric heater turned on with an empty tank burns out its elements.

  4. Check the setting

    The U.S. Department of Energy suggests 120°F for most homes. Water much hotter than that can scald skin in seconds, and higher settings work sediment harder.

  5. Find the age

    The serial number on the label usually encodes the manufacture date. HomeGuide puts tank heaters at 8 to 15 years. An old tank that rumbles even after flushing is nearing replacement.

Avoid these

  • Plugging, capping or removing the T&P relief valve or its discharge pipe.
  • Working on gas valves, burners, thermocouples or electric elements.
  • Forcing an old drain valve that won't open or reseal. Plastic drain valves can break and leak. If the tank is several years old and has never been flushed, consider having a plumber do the first flush.

When to call a pro

  • You hear hissing or sizzling, or see any leak.
  • The T&P valve drips or discharges.
  • Popping or rumbling continues after a flush.
  • Screeching continues with all the valves open.
  • The tank is past about 10 years old and acting up.

If banging comes from the pipes when a faucet or appliance shuts off, ask the plumber about a water hammer arrestor and checking your water pressure.

Typical repair costs

National ranges from HomeGuide for tank water heater repairs, including parts and labor.

Repair Typical cost Source
Typical tank water heater repair $150–$700 HomeGuide
Professional flush $75–$200 HomeGuide
Anode rod replacement $150–$350 HomeGuide
Heating element replacement (electric) $100–$350 HomeGuide
T&P relief valve replacement $50–$300 HomeGuide
Gas control valve replacement $150–$550 HomeGuide
Expansion tank installation $300–$800 HomeGuide
Service call $50–$200 HomeGuide

HomeGuide suggests replacing rather than repairing when the tank is over 10 years old or the repair would cost more than half of a new heater. A leaking tank usually means replacement.

Frequently asked questions

Is a noisy water heater dangerous?

Quiet ticking, humming and gurgling are normal. Popping and rumbling usually mean sediment. Hissing, sizzling or a discharging relief valve need prompt attention.

Will flushing stop the popping noise?

Often, yes. Flushing removes the sediment that traps steam bubbles. If the tank has years of buildup, a plumber may need to do a more thorough cleaning, or the tank may be near the end of its life.

Why does my water heater bang when I turn off a faucet?

That is usually water hammer in the pipes rather than a heater problem. A water hammer arrestor, lower water pressure or securing loose pipes usually fixes it.

How often should I flush my water heater?

At least once a year, more often if you have hard water.

Sources

  1. Hot Water Heater Making Noises , A.O. Smith
  2. The Ultimate Guide to Water Heater Noises , Rheem
  3. Water Heater Repair Cost , HomeGuide