Stop and call a pro now if
- You smell gas (a rotten-egg smell) near a gas water heater. Leave the house right away. Don't switch lights or appliances on or off, use a phone or light anything inside. Call your gas utility or 911 from outside.
- Your CO alarm sounds near a gas heater. Get everyone out and call 911.
- The relief valve on the tank is releasing hot water or steam. Stay clear of the discharge pipe, turn off the power or gas to the heater, and call a plumber.
- Water is pooling under the tank or spraying from a fitting. Turn off the cold water supply valve on top of the heater and turn off its power or gas. Don't stand in water to reach the breaker panel.
- The breaker for an electric heater trips again after you reset it once. That points to a short, so leave it off.
- You see scorch marks, soot or melted wiring at the heater.
Likely causes
-
A tripped breaker (electric)
A.O. Smith calls a tripped breaker a very common reason an electric water heater stops working. A breaker that keeps tripping usually means a shorted element or a wiring fault.
-
The high-limit switch tripped (electric)
The red reset button behind the upper access panel cuts power when the water gets too hot. A.O. Smith says a grounded element or a faulty thermostat is often behind it, so a trip that repeats needs a diagnosis.
-
A failed heating element or thermostat (electric)
If the lower element fails, you still get some hot water but it runs out quickly. If the upper element or the upper thermostat fails, you get none, because the upper thermostat controls power to both elements.
-
The pilot is out or the burner won't light (gas)
A closed gas valve, a gas supply problem, a worn thermocouple or a failed igniter keeps the burner from firing. A pilot that won't stay lit often comes down to the thermocouple.
-
A power-vent heater lost power (gas)
Some gas heaters have an electric vent blower on top and need a working outlet. If it is unplugged or its outlet has tripped, the burner won't run.
-
A failed gas control valve (gas)
The control on the front of the tank regulates gas to the burner. When it fails, the burner won't light even with gas available.
-
Blocked combustion air (gas)
A.O. Smith notes that clogged air screens or filters at the base of some gas heaters restrict combustion air and affect the burner.
-
A tankless unit has scaled up or shut down
On a tankless heater, mineral buildup, an ignition failure or a venting fault can stop it. Most show an error code on the front panel.
What you can safely check
Find out first whether the heater is gas or electric. A gas heater has a gas line and a vent pipe on top; an electric one has a power cable and no flame.
-
Check other taps
If only one fixture is cold, the problem is that fixture's valve or mixing cartridge, not the heater.
-
Electric: check the breaker
Look for the double breaker labeled for the water heater. If it has tripped, switch it fully off, then on, once.
-
Electric: press the reset button
With the breaker off, remove the upper access panel and insulation and press the red reset button. Put the cover back before turning the breaker on. If it trips again, call a plumber.
-
Gas: check the gas valve and pilot
Make sure the gas valve on the supply line is open and that other gas appliances work. If your heater has a sight glass, look through it for the pilot flame. Many newer gas controls have a status light that blinks a fault code, explained on the tank label.
-
Gas: relight the pilot by the label
Follow the lighting instructions on the tank label. A.O. Smith says to turn the control to Off and wait 10 minutes for gas to clear before relighting. If the pilot won't stay lit after a try or two, stop.
-
Tankless: read the error code
Write down the code on the display and look it up in the owner's manual before resetting anything.
-
Give it time
After power or flame comes back, A.O. Smith puts recovery at about 30 to 40 minutes for a gas tank and 60 to 90 minutes for an electric one.
Avoid these
- Removing access panels or touching wiring on an electric heater with the breaker on. A.O. Smith warns the components stay live even when the unit isn't heating.
- Relighting a pilot if you smell gas, or over and over when it keeps going out.
- Lifting the temperature and pressure relief valve lever on a hot tank to test it. Scalding water can shoot out. Leave that test to a plumber.
When to call a pro
- The breaker or reset button trips again after one reset.
- The pilot won't light or won't stay lit.
- You have power and gas, but the water still won't heat.
- The tank is leaking, or it is more than about 10 years old and needs a major part.
Tell the plumber whether the heater is gas or electric, its age from the label, and what you saw: a tripped breaker, a red reset button that popped, or a pilot that won't stay lit. That points the visit at an element, thermostat, thermocouple or gas control.
Typical repair costs
National ranges for parts and labor from HomeGuide. Gas and electric parts differ, and after-hours calls cost more.
| Repair | Typical cost | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Typical water heater repair | $150–$700 | HomeGuide |
| Heating element replacement | $100–$350 | HomeGuide |
| Thermostat replacement | $100–$350 | HomeGuide |
| Thermocouple replacement | $100–$325 | HomeGuide |
| Igniter replacement | $75–$350 | HomeGuide |
| Gas control valve replacement | $150–$550 | HomeGuide |
| New tank water heater, installed | $600–$1,800 | HomeGuide |
Frequently asked questions
Why do I have no hot water but the pilot light is on?
On a gas heater with a lit pilot, the burner may not be getting the signal or gas to light. The thermostat setting, the gas control or a sediment-choked burner are common causes. If turning the temperature dial up doesn't light the burner, call a plumber.
Why does my electric water heater keep tripping the breaker?
A breaker that trips more than once usually means a shorted heating element, a grounded wire or a failed thermostat. Leave it off and have it checked rather than resetting it again.
How long does it take to get hot water back?
Once the heater is working, A.O. Smith puts recovery at about 30 to 40 minutes for a gas tank and 60 to 90 minutes for an electric one.
Is it worth repairing an old water heater?
A thermostat, element or thermocouple is usually worth fixing. A leaking tank is not repairable and means replacement.
Sources
- Is Your Hot Water Not Getting Hot? Common Causes & What To Do About Them , A.O. Smith
- How To Relight A Water Heater's Pilot Light , A.O. Smith
- Water Heater Repair Cost , HomeGuide