1. What did you measure, and what are the numbers?
A thorough service call produces measurements — refrigerant pressures, temperature split (should be 15–22°F for AC), static pressure (under 0.8 iwc), and capacitor values. A tech who says 'everything looks good' without numbers didn't do a complete inspection.
Pro tip: Write down numbers or get a printed report. Compare year to year. Slowly declining refrigerant pressures indicate a leak.
2. Is this a repair or should I start planning for replacement?
Not every repair is worth making. Ask the tech: given the system's age, condition, and repair cost, would they repair or replace their own system? General rule: if repair costs more than 50% of replacement value and the system is over 10 years old, replacement usually makes sense.
Pro tip: Ask about refrigerant type. R-22 systems face $50–$150/pound refrigerant costs with no new supply being produced.
3. Can you show me the problem before you fix it?
A trustworthy technician will show you the failed part or dirty coil. This isn't distrust — it's education. Seeing a swollen capacitor or frozen coil helps you understand and prevent future problems.
Pro tip: Take a photo before repair. Useful for second opinions, recurring problems, or warranty claims.
4. What's causing this problem — not just what broke?
There's a difference between replacing a part and fixing the root cause. A capacitor that failed at 3 years might indicate voltage issues or oversizing. A frozen coil might mean a refrigerant leak. Ask what caused the failure.
Pro tip: If the same component fails twice in 2 years, push for root cause diagnosis. Don't accept 'these things just fail sometimes.'
5. What does this repair include — parts, labor, and warranty?
Get a clear breakdown before approving repairs over $200: parts cost, labor charge, warranty terms and duration, fixed vs. time-and-materials pricing. Labor warranties should be at least 90 days.
Pro tip: Ask if the warranty covers the failure mode or just the specific part. A compressor with 5-year parts warranty but no labor warranty means $500–$1,000 in labor if it fails again.
6. Is my system properly sized for my home?
Oversized systems short-cycle, waste energy, and dehumidify poorly. Undersized systems run constantly. Signs of oversizing: cools in 10–15 minutes then shuts off, humidity stays high. A Manual J load calculation ($200–$400) gives the definitive answer.
Pro tip: For new system quotes, require Manual J. Any contractor who sizes by rule of thumb will likely oversize.
7. What can I do between visits to keep the system running well?
Good techs want you to maintain between visits. The answer should include: filter schedule and MERV rating, drain flushing, outdoor unit clearance, and system-specific items.
Pro tip: Ask the tech to show you the condensate drain access, filter location, and early warning signs. Five minutes of education saves hours of troubleshooting.
8. Are there rebates or tax credits I should know about?
Federal, state, and utility rebates can reduce upgrade costs by $500–$5,000+. Your tech should know the current tax credit structure and local rebates. If not, check DSIRE and your utility company.
Pro tip: Some rebates require pre-approval before installation. Confirm timing requirements before scheduling.
9. What brand and model are you installing, and why?
For replacement quotes, ask for specific model numbers, the AHRI certificate confirming matched indoor/outdoor units, and the SEER2/HSPF2 rating of that specific pair.
Pro tip: Look up the AHRI reference number at ahridirectory.org. Contractors sometimes quote high SEER condensers with mismatched air handlers.
10. Can I see your license, insurance, and the permit for this work?
Licensed contractors carry state licenses, liability insurance, and workers' comp. For installations, most jurisdictions require a mechanical permit. A contractor who discourages permits may be cutting corners.
Pro tip: Call your building department to verify permit requirements. If the contractor says it's not needed but the department says it is, trust the department.