1. What is your prep process for this specific siding material?
A quality painter tailors prep to the substrate. Wood clapboard requires scraping, sanding, and spot-priming. Fiber cement needs only washing and priming bare areas. Stucco requires patching cracks and applying a masonry primer. If the answer is generic — 'we pressure wash and paint' — the contractor treats every surface the same, which means corners get cut on the surfaces that need more work. The prep answer reveals more about the final result than any paint brand discussion.
Pro tip: Ask to see photos of their prep work on a similar siding type. Quality contractors document prep because they know it is what separates them from budget operators.
2. How many coats are included, and what products are you using?
A proper exterior repaint is one coat of primer (where needed) plus two coats of finish paint. One coat of finish over primer is not enough for full hide and durability. Ask for the specific product names — a contractor using Sherwin-Williams Duration, Benjamin Moore Aura, or equivalent professional-grade paint is spending $50–$70 per gallon. A contractor using $25 builder-grade paint is cutting costs where it matters most. The paint itself is 10–15% of the total job cost; cheap paint saves the contractor $200–$400 but costs you 3–5 years of longevity.
Pro tip: Ask the contractor to leave the empty paint cans on site so you can verify the product matches the bid. This is standard practice among quality contractors.
3. Are you EPA RRP-certified for pre-1978 homes?
Federal law requires contractors disturbing more than 6 square feet of paint on pre-1978 homes to hold EPA Renovation, Repair, and Painting (RRP) certification. This covers lead-safe work practices — plastic sheeting, HEPA vacuuming, wet scraping, and proper disposal. A contractor who does not mention RRP when bidding a pre-1978 home is either unaware of the law or plans to ignore it. Both are disqualifying. Fines for non-compliance are up to $37,500 per day per violation.
Pro tip: Ask to see the EPA RRP firm certificate and the individual lead-safe renovator card. Both are required — the firm is certified and at least one trained renovator must be on site.
4. What does your warranty cover — labor, materials, or both?
Paint manufacturer warranties cover the product only and require proof of proper application. Contractor labor warranties cover the workmanship. You need both. A contractor offering 'a 5-year warranty' without specifying what it covers is likely offering nothing enforceable. Get the warranty in writing with clear terms: what is covered, what voids it, what the contractor will do if paint fails prematurely, and whether the warranty transfers if you sell the home.
Pro tip: A labor warranty longer than the contractor's average business lifespan is meaningless. Check how long the company has been operating — a 10-year warranty from a 2-year-old company is a red flag.
5. How do you handle wood rot and damaged substrate?
Every exterior has some rot — window sills, trim ends near the ground, and bottom siding courses are common locations. A quality contractor includes a rot inspection in the bid process and specifies how they will handle it: cut and replace, use epoxy consolidant, or refer to a carpenter. A contractor who does not mention rot either has not looked closely or plans to paint over it. Painting over soft wood costs you twice — the paint fails within a year, and the rot spreads.
Pro tip: Ask for a rot allowance in the contract — a set dollar amount for minor repairs included in the bid, with a clear per-hour or per-board-foot rate for anything beyond that. This prevents surprise change orders.
6. Will you scrape and spot-prime all bare wood, or just top-coat?
Bare wood exposed by scraping needs primer before topcoat. Paint applied directly to bare wood soaks in unevenly, resulting in poor adhesion and visible grain-raise within the first year. Spot-priming every scraped area adds significant labor time, which is why budget contractors skip it. If a contractor does not mention spot-priming as a separate step, ask directly. The answer tells you whether they understand adhesion or are just applying color.
Pro tip: An exterior wood primer should be applied within 48 hours of scraping. Bare wood left exposed for weeks absorbs moisture and UV, which degrades the surface and reduces primer adhesion.
7. How do you protect landscaping, windows, and adjacent surfaces?
Overspray on windows, drips on shrubs, and paint on concrete are common damage from careless crews. A quality contractor specifies their masking and drop-cloth process. At minimum: plastic sheeting over landscaping within the drip zone, paper or tape on window glass, and drop cloths on walkways and driveways. If a contractor says 'we're careful' without describing a specific protection process, expect cleanup issues or damage claims.
Pro tip: Walk the perimeter with the contractor before work starts and photograph existing conditions — landscaping, windows, concrete, roofing. This baseline protects both parties from disputes over pre-existing damage.
8. Can you provide three references from exterior jobs completed 2+ years ago?
A paint job looks good the day it is finished. The real test is year two and beyond. Asking for references from jobs completed 2–3 years ago reveals whether the prep work held up. Call the references and ask one question: has any paint peeled, blistered, or failed? If the contractor cannot provide aged references, they are either new to the business or their work does not hold up — both are risks on a $5K–$15K investment.
Pro tip: Ask references whether the contractor handled any warranty claims. How a contractor responds to failure is more revealing than how they perform under ideal conditions.
9. What is your crew size and timeline for this project?
A single painter on a full-house exterior will take 2–3 weeks. A crew of 3–4 painters finishes the same house in 4–6 days. Longer timelines increase weather exposure risk — partially painted surfaces sitting through rain or dew can cause adhesion problems at the overlap lines. But too fast can mean rushing prep. Ask for the crew size, daily schedule, and what happens if weather delays the project. A clear timeline with contingency plans signals a contractor who manages jobs rather than winging them.
Pro tip: Ask if the same crew works the entire job. Rotating crews lose continuity on prep areas, overlap lines, and color matching — especially on multi-color trim work.
Bonus Tip
Get three bids and compare line items, not just totals
A $6,000 bid and an $11,000 bid may include radically different scopes of work. Break each bid into prep, materials, labor, and extras. The lowest bid almost always cuts prep time and uses cheaper paint. The highest bid may include unnecessary extras. The middle bid with detailed line items is usually the best starting point for comparison.
What to Avoid
- Choosing a painter based on price alone — the cheapest bid almost always means less prep, fewer coats, or lower-grade paint, all of which shorten the job's lifespan.
- Accepting a bid that does not specify paint product names and sheen levels — 'premium exterior paint' is not a product specification.
- Hiring a contractor without verifying their insurance — a worker injured on your property without workers' comp coverage becomes your liability.
- Signing a contract without a written scope of work that includes prep steps, number of coats, and rot repair terms.