1. Does the scope include full tear-off or just an overlay?
This is the biggest cost difference on any roof claim. A tear-off (removing existing shingles down to the deck) costs $1,000–$3,000 more than an overlay (layering new shingles on top of old ones). If your roof already has two layers, building code requires a tear-off — but some adjusters scope an overlay regardless. If the scope says 'recover' or 'overlay,' ask why, and request a tear-off if code requires it or if the decking needs inspection for water damage.
Pro tip: Ask your contractor to count existing layers before you agree to the scope. If there are two layers, the scope must include tear-off per IBC Section R907.3.
2. Are all roof penetrations and flashing included in the line items?
Adjusters frequently scope shingle replacement but omit flashing around chimneys, pipe boots, wall step-flashing, and vent collars. These items cost $150–$600 each and are where most post-repair leaks originate. Count the penetrations on your roof and verify each one has a corresponding line item in the scope. If the adjuster omitted them, request a supplement — flashing that was intact before the storm but must be disturbed during shingle replacement is covered under most policies.
Pro tip: Pipe boot replacement alone runs $75–$150 per unit installed. If your roof has 4–6 plumbing vents, that's $300–$900 the adjuster may have missed.
3. Does the scope account for code upgrades required by current building code?
When your roof was installed 15–20 years ago, the building code may have been different. Most policies include 'code upgrade' coverage (sometimes called 'ordinance or law' coverage) that pays for bringing the repair up to current standards. Common code upgrades include ice-and-water shield at eaves, drip edge on all edges, and specific nail patterns. If the scope uses old-code specs, you're leaving money on the table and the repair may not pass inspection.
Pro tip: Ask your contractor what the current local code requires for a re-roof. Compare that list against the scope line items. Any gap is a supplement opportunity.
4. What measurements did the adjuster use for roof area?
Adjusters use satellite imagery (EagleView, Hover, or similar) to measure roof area. These reports are generally accurate but can undercount by 5–10% on complex roofs with dormers, hips, and steep pitches. Ask to see the measurement report. If your contractor's measurement exceeds the adjuster's by more than 5%, request a re-measurement — the difference on a 2,500 sq ft roof is 125 sq ft, or roughly $500–$1,000 in materials and labor.
Pro tip: Steep-slope waste factor should be 10–15% on a complex roof. If the scope lists only 5% waste, the shingle count is short and the contractor will eat the difference or cut corners.
5. Is the scope priced at replacement cost or actual cash value?
This determines how much you actually get paid. Replacement Cost Value (RCV) pays the full cost of new materials and labor. Actual Cash Value (ACV) deducts depreciation based on roof age — on a 15-year-old roof, that depreciation can be 40–60% of the total, leaving you with a check that doesn't cover the repair. Check your policy declarations page and the scope summary. If the scope shows a 'depreciation holdback,' you'll receive the rest only after repairs are completed and invoiced.
Pro tip: If your policy is RCV, the insurer typically sends an initial check minus depreciation, then releases the depreciation holdback when you submit the contractor's final invoice. Make sure your contractor knows this payment structure.
6. Are gutters, downspouts, and soffit included if they were damaged?
Storm damage rarely limits itself to shingles. Wind bends gutters, hail dents downspouts, and displaced siding exposes soffit. If your inspection found damage to these components, verify they appear in the scope. Adjusters sometimes treat these as separate claims or omit them entirely. A full gutter replacement runs $1,000–$2,500, and soffit repair adds $500–$1,500. These are legitimate storm-damage items that belong in the same claim.
Pro tip: If the adjuster says gutters are a separate claim, ask why. Most policies cover all storm damage to the dwelling structure under a single deductible.
7. What is the labor rate and does it match your local market?
Insurance scopes use pricing databases like Xactimate that set labor rates by ZIP code. Occasionally the rate is set to a region-wide average that's lower than what contractors actually charge in your specific market. If every contractor you bid comes in significantly higher than the scope, the labor rate may be wrong. Ask the adjuster what labor rate per square (100 sq ft) the scope uses and compare it to your contractor's bid. If there's a meaningful gap, request a rate adjustment.
Pro tip: Xactimate pricing is updated monthly. If the adjuster used an outdated price list, material and labor rates may be 5–10% below current market. Ask when the price list was last updated.
8. Can you get a copy of the full Xactimate report, not just the summary?
Adjusters often send homeowners a one-page summary showing the total payout. The full Xactimate report is 5–15 pages and shows every individual line item: shingle squares, underlayment, flashing, labor, overhead, profit, and code upgrades. You need the full report to compare against contractor bids and identify missing items. You are entitled to a copy — ask for it in your initial claim call and again when the scope is finalized. Your contractor needs it too for accurate supplementing.
Pro tip: Send the full Xactimate report to at least two contractors and ask each one to identify line items that are missing or underpriced. This is the basis for a supplement request.
Bonus Tip
You have the right to request a re-inspection
If you believe the adjuster missed damage or underscoped the repair, you can request a re-inspection at no cost. Have your contractor present during the re-inspection to point out items the adjuster missed. Many claims increase by 20–40% after a re-inspection with a knowledgeable contractor on site.
What to Avoid
- Signing the scope as 'accepted' before a contractor reviews it — once accepted, getting supplements approved is significantly harder.
- Assuming the adjuster's scope is the final word — it's an estimate, not a contract, and supplements are a normal part of the process.
- Letting a contractor pressure you into signing a work authorization before you've reviewed the scope — you should always compare scope to contractor bid first.
- Cashing the insurance check and using it for non-repair expenses — if you have a mortgage, the check may be co-payable with your lender and must go toward actual repairs.