1. What is your fee structure, and is it negotiable?
Public adjusters typically charge 10–15% of the total claim payout on a contingency basis, meaning they only get paid when you do. However, some charge as much as 20–33% in disaster-declared areas when demand surges. The fee should be negotiable—especially on larger claims over $20,000 where the adjuster's work-to-payout ratio improves. On a $15,000 roof claim, a 10% fee costs you $1,500 while a 20% fee costs $3,000 for the same work. Always negotiate before signing.
Pro tip: Ask for a sliding scale: 15% on the first $10,000 recovered and 10% on everything above that. Many public adjusters will agree because it still incentivizes them to maximize your claim while saving you money on larger payouts.
2. Are you licensed in my state, and can I verify it?
Public adjusters must be licensed by the state department of insurance in every state where they operate. An unlicensed adjuster has no legal authority to negotiate with your insurer and any contract with them may be void. Ask for their license number and verify it on your state's department of insurance website. After major storms, unlicensed individuals often pose as public adjusters to collect upfront fees, so verification is critical—not optional.
Pro tip: Check not just that the license exists, but that it's active and has no disciplinary actions. Most state DOI websites show complaint history and any formal sanctions against the license holder.
3. How many roof damage claims have you handled in the past 12 months?
Roof claims have specific nuances—Xactimate line items, code upgrade provisions, depreciation schedules for different shingle types—that general property adjusters may not know well. You want someone who has handled at least 20–30 roof-specific claims in the past year. An adjuster who primarily handles water damage, fire, or commercial claims may not know how to argue for proper ice-and-water shield coverage or challenge an insurer's shingle depreciation calculation.
Pro tip: Ask for two or three references from recent roof claim clients in your area. A confident public adjuster will share these without hesitation. Call the references and ask specifically whether the final payout was significantly higher than the insurer's initial offer.
4. What is your average recovery above the insurer's initial offer?
A good public adjuster should be able to tell you their track record. Industry data shows that public adjusters recover an average of 30–50% more than the initial insurance offer on underpaid claims. If the adjuster can't cite a specific average or gives a vague answer like "we always get more," they may lack the experience to meaningfully improve your outcome. Ask for specific examples: "On a claim that was initially offered $8,000, what did you ultimately recover?"
Pro tip: Be cautious of adjusters who promise specific dollar amounts before inspecting your roof. A legitimate public adjuster will tell you they need to assess the damage before estimating potential recovery.
5. What exactly will you do that I can't do myself?
A public adjuster should provide measurable value: writing a detailed Xactimate estimate, identifying damage the insurer missed, negotiating supplements, and if necessary, invoking the appraisal clause in your policy. If their answer is simply "we handle everything," press harder. On straightforward claims under $5,000 with clear-cut damage, a public adjuster's 10–15% fee may not be worth it. Their value increases dramatically on complex, disputed, or underpaid claims above $10,000.
Pro tip: The strongest public adjusters write their own Xactimate estimates independently of any roofer's bid. This gives you two professional damage assessments to present to the insurer rather than one.
How to do it:
- Ask them to describe their process step by step, from initial inspection to final settlement.
- Ask whether they personally inspect the roof or send a subcontracted inspector.
- Ask if they write their own Xactimate estimates or rely on a roofer's estimate.
- Ask what happens if the supplement is denied—will they pursue appraisal?
6. Do you have a relationship with specific roofing contractors?
Some public adjusters have referral arrangements with roofing contractors where they steer clients to specific roofers in exchange for a fee. This creates a conflict of interest because the adjuster's job is to maximize your claim, not to source your contractor. Ask directly whether they receive any compensation from roofing companies. A truly independent public adjuster should be indifferent to which roofer you hire and should never require you to use a specific contractor.
Pro tip: If a public adjuster and roofer show up at your door together, that's a red flag. Legitimate public adjusters and roofers serve different roles, and bundling them together often means one is getting a kickback from the other.
7. What does the cancellation clause in your contract look like?
Before signing, read the cancellation terms carefully. Reputable public adjusters offer a 3–5 day cancellation window with no penalty, which is also required by law in many states. Some contracts include clauses that entitle the adjuster to their full fee even if you cancel before settlement, or that charge a flat cancellation fee of $500–$1,500. The best contracts tie the fee strictly to contingency: if they recover nothing, you owe nothing, and you can cancel within the legal window at zero cost.
Pro tip: Check your state's specific cancellation rights for public adjuster contracts. Florida, for example, mandates a minimum 5-business-day cancellation period for contracts signed at home, while Texas requires 3 days. These rights override anything the contract says.
8. Will you keep me informed throughout the process, and how often?
A roof claim with supplements can take 60–120 days to resolve, and the worst experience is hearing nothing from your public adjuster for weeks. Before signing, establish communication expectations: weekly email updates, a phone call after every interaction with the insurer, and immediate notification of any offers or denials. Ask how many active claims they're currently managing—if they have more than 40–50 at once, your claim may not get the attention it needs.
Pro tip: Ask the adjuster if they'll give you access to any claim management software or portal where you can check status. More sophisticated public adjusting firms use these tools, and access to your claim status reduces anxiety and phone calls.
9. Have you ever had a license suspended or a formal complaint filed against you?
This is an uncomfortable but necessary question. Public adjusters who've had disciplinary action may still be licensed and operating. Ask directly and then verify independently through your state's department of insurance complaint database. One complaint in 10 years of practice is understandable; multiple complaints or a suspension is disqualifying. Also check the Better Business Bureau and Google Reviews for patterns of non-communication or unfulfilled promises.
Pro tip: Search the adjuster's name plus "complaint" or "lawsuit" in your state's court records system. Civil suits from former clients often reveal issues that DOI complaints don't capture.
10. What happens if we go to appraisal—are you experienced in that process?
If supplements and negotiations fail, the appraisal clause in your policy is the next step. Appraisal involves each side hiring an appraiser, and the two appraisers select an umpire whose decision is binding. Not all public adjusters have appraisal experience, and the process requires different skills than standard negotiation. Appraisal typically costs $500–$1,500 in umpire fees but recovers an average of $4,000–$8,000 on underpaid roof claims. Ask how many appraisals the adjuster has participated in and what their success rate is.
Pro tip: Some public adjusters cap their contingency fee on appraisal proceeds at a lower rate than on negotiated settlements. Ask about this upfront—on a $10,000 appraisal recovery, the difference between 10% and 15% is $500 to you.
How to do it:
- Ask the adjuster how many appraisals they've participated in over the past 2 years.
- Ask about their average recovery through the appraisal process.
- Clarify who pays the umpire fee—you, the adjuster, or split.
- Confirm the adjuster's fee percentage applies to appraisal proceeds as well.
Bonus Tip
Consider timing before hiring a public adjuster
Public adjusters add the most value when brought in early—ideally before or right after the insurer's first inspection. Hiring one after you've already accepted a settlement is harder because reopening a closed claim requires proving new evidence. If your claim is still open and you're unhappy with the offer, now is the optimal time. If the claim is already closed, ask the adjuster specifically whether they can reopen it before you sign a contract.
What to Avoid
- Do not sign a public adjuster contract at your front door during a high-pressure sales pitch—take at least 24 hours to review the terms and research the adjuster's credentials.
- Do not hire a public adjuster who demands any upfront fee before work begins—legitimate public adjusters work on contingency and get paid only from the claim proceeds.
- Do not assume a public adjuster replaces the need for a qualified roofer—you still need a licensed contractor to perform the actual repairs, and the adjuster handles only the insurance side.
- Do not sign a contract that gives the public adjuster authority to accept settlement offers on your behalf without your written approval—you should always have final say on any settlement amount.