1. Ask the roofer if they have experience working with insurance claims specifically
Not all roofers understand insurance processes, Xactimate pricing, or supplement procedures. A roofer who does 80% insurance work and 20% retail speaks the adjuster's language -- they know line-item codes, understand depreciation schedules, and can identify commonly missed items on the spot. A roofer who primarily does new construction may be an excellent craftsman but will struggle to advocate effectively during an insurance inspection.
Pro tip: Ask how many insurance supplement claims they've filed in the past year. An experienced insurance roofer files 30-50+ supplements annually. If they can't answer this question or seem unfamiliar with the supplement process, they're not the right contractor for an insurance-driven repair.
2. Ask whether they'll advocate for your interests or just agree with the adjuster
Some contractors attend adjuster meetings and passively accept whatever the adjuster scopes. Others treat the meeting as a negotiation and respectfully point out damage the adjuster missed. You want the second type. Ask the roofer directly: 'If the adjuster misses damage, will you speak up during the inspection or file a supplement afterward?' The answer reveals whether they'll fight for a fair scope or rubber-stamp whatever keeps the process easy.
Pro tip: The best insurance-experienced roofers bring their own Xactimate estimate to the adjuster meeting. This forces a line-by-line comparison and makes it much harder for the adjuster to omit legitimate damage items.
3. Ask if they've already prepared a written damage assessment and estimate
Your roofer should arrive at the adjuster meeting with a complete, written damage report including photos, measurements, and a line-item estimate. Walking in with nothing and just 'pointing stuff out' is far less effective. A prepared roofer with documented evidence positions the meeting as a collaborative review of known damage, not a discovery session where things get missed. This preparation typically takes 1-2 hours and should be done before the adjuster appointment.
Pro tip: Ask for a copy of their damage report before the adjuster meeting so you can review it. You should understand every item your roofer plans to highlight -- this prevents surprises and lets you ask informed questions during the inspection.
4. Ask whether they charge a fee for attending the adjuster meeting
Most reputable insurance-focused roofers attend adjuster meetings at no charge as part of their service -- it's how they ensure the claim covers the full scope of work. However, some contractors charge $150-$300 for the meeting, which is reasonable if they're providing a detailed damage report and Xactimate estimate. What's not acceptable is a contractor who charges for the meeting AND expects you to sign a contract before attending. That's a hostage negotiation, not a service.
Pro tip: If a contractor offers to attend for free, confirm in writing that there's no obligation to hire them if the claim is approved. Free adjuster meeting attendance should not come with strings attached -- it's a standard industry practice, not a favor.
5. Ask if they'll let you be present during the meeting or expect to handle it alone
You should absolutely attend the adjuster-roofer meeting. It's your home, your claim, and your money. A roofer who insists on meeting the adjuster without you present is a red flag -- they may be negotiating terms that benefit them more than you, or worse, agreeing to inflate the scope in exchange for winning the job. Be physically present, take notes, and ask questions. You're the decision-maker, and both the adjuster and roofer work for you.
Pro tip: Stand between the roofer and adjuster rather than off to the side. Being physically central to the conversation ensures both parties direct their explanations to you and makes it natural for you to ask questions.
6. Ask whether they have any financial relationship with your insurance company
Some roofing contractors participate in insurance company 'preferred vendor' programs that provide them a steady stream of referrals in exchange for agreed-upon pricing -- pricing that's typically 15-25% below market rate. While these contractors are often competent, their financial incentive is to keep the insurance company happy, not to maximize your claim. Ask directly whether they're in any preferred vendor or managed repair network with your specific insurer.
Pro tip: A preferred-network roofer isn't necessarily bad, but understand the dynamic: they may avoid challenging the adjuster's scope because doing so jeopardizes their preferred status. An independent roofer has no such constraint.
7. Ask what happens if the adjuster's scope and the roofer's scope disagree
Disagreements between adjusters and roofers are common -- they happen on roughly 60-70% of storm damage claims. Ask the roofer upfront how they handle it: Will they file a formal supplement with supporting documentation? Will they request a re-inspection? Do they have experience with the appraisal or umpire process if the dispute escalates? A roofer who says 'we'll just work with whatever the insurance approves' isn't fighting for you.
Pro tip: Ask the roofer for an example of a recent supplement they filed and the outcome. Experienced insurance roofers can rattle off specific examples -- 'we supplemented $4,200 for code upgrades and decking replacement on a job last month and got full approval.' Vague answers suggest limited experience.
How to do it:
- Ask the roofer to describe their supplement filing process step by step
- Ask for the success rate of their supplements (good contractors recover 70-85%)
- Ask whether they've ever used the appraisal clause in a policy to resolve disputes
- Confirm they'll handle the supplement paperwork at no additional charge to you
8. Ask if they require you to sign a contract before the adjuster meeting
Beware of contractors who require a signed contract as a condition of attending the adjuster meeting. This locks you into using them before you know the full claim scope or payout amount. You should have the freedom to compare the adjuster's estimate with multiple contractor bids before committing. A contingency agreement (you only hire them if the claim is approved) is reasonable; a binding contract before the claim is even filed is not.
Pro tip: Read every document the roofer asks you to sign before the adjuster meeting. Some 'authorization to inspect' forms contain hidden contract language that commits you to using that contractor. If it mentions pricing, payment terms, or cancellation fees, it's a contract -- not an authorization.
9. Ask how they'll communicate the adjuster meeting results to you afterward
After the meeting, you need a clear written summary of what was discussed, what the adjuster agreed to include, what was disputed, and what next steps are required. Ask the roofer whether they'll provide a written recap within 24 hours. Verbal-only communication leads to misunderstandings, lost details, and he-said-she-said disputes weeks later when the estimate arrives and doesn't match what you remember being discussed.
Pro tip: Take your own notes during the meeting and email them to both the roofer and adjuster within 24 hours with the subject line 'Recap of inspection on [date].' This creates a written record that all three parties can reference and correct while details are fresh.
Bonus Tip
Record the adjuster meeting on your phone (where legal)
In one-party consent states (38 states as of 2026), you can legally record the conversation as long as you are present. In two-party consent states, simply inform both the roofer and adjuster that you'd like to record for your records -- most will agree. A recording captures every commitment, measurement, and damage item discussed, and it prevents the common scenario where the written estimate omits items that were verbally agreed to during the inspection.
What to Avoid
- Letting a roofer you haven't vetted attend the adjuster meeting -- an unprofessional or aggressive contractor can antagonize the adjuster and hurt your claim outcome
- Signing an assignment of benefits (AOB) before the adjuster meeting -- this transfers your claim control to the contractor and can result in inflated invoices that raise your future premiums
- Allowing the roofer and adjuster to conduct the inspection privately without you -- you lose visibility into what was discussed and agreed upon, making it easy for either party to misrepresent the outcome
- Assuming the roofer's presence alone guarantees a better payout -- an unprepared roofer without documentation or Xactimate experience adds little value and may actually undermine your credibility