12 Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Roofer (Avoid Getting Scammed)

1. Are you licensed and insured in this state?

Every legitimate roofer carries general liability insurance ($1M minimum) and workers' compensation. Ask for certificate of insurance and verify it's current — call the insurance company directly. If a worker falls off your roof and the contractor has no workers' comp, YOU can be sued. In 37 states, roofing contractors must hold a specific license.

Pro tip: Verify the license number on your state's contractor licensing board website. It takes 2 minutes and catches 90% of scammers.

2. How long have you been in business under this name?

Storm chasers set up shop after major weather events, do poor work, then dissolve the company before warranties kick in. Look for 5+ years under the same business name, a physical office (not a PO Box), and a verifiable track record. Check their Better Business Bureau profile and Google reviews — but be wary of companies with only 5-star reviews and no photos.

Pro tip: Search the company name + 'complaints' or 'lawsuit' in your state court records. Public records reveal patterns that review sites don't.

3. Can I see your manufacturer certifications?

Major shingle manufacturers (GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning) offer certification programs that require training and quality standards. A GAF Master Elite contractor (only 3% of roofers qualify) can offer 50-year warranties that cover both materials AND labor. An uncertified installer using the same shingles may void the manufacturer's warranty entirely.

Pro tip: GAF, CertainTeed, and Owens Corning all have online directories of certified contractors. If a roofer claims certification, verify it on the manufacturer's website.

4. Will you provide a written, itemized estimate?

A proper estimate should break down: materials (shingle type, underlayment, flashing), labor, tear-off and disposal, permits, and any structural repairs. Vague estimates like 'roof replacement — $12,000' are a red flag. The national average for a full roof replacement is $8,000-$15,000 for asphalt shingles on a 2,000 sq ft home.

Pro tip: Get 3 written estimates minimum. If one is dramatically lower than the others, they're likely cutting corners on materials or skipping steps like proper underlayment.

5. What happens if you find damage under the shingles?

Rotted decking, damaged trusses, or mold under old shingles are common surprises during tear-off. A good contractor will have a per-sheet price for plywood replacement ($75-$150 per sheet) written into the contract BEFORE work begins. Without this, you'll get a panic call mid-project demanding thousands more.

Pro tip: Ask for a 'not to exceed' clause for decking replacement — e.g., up to 10 sheets included at $X each, anything beyond requires your written approval.

6. Who will actually be on my roof — employees or subcontractors?

Many roofing companies are brokers — they sell the job and hire subcontractors to do the work. This isn't automatically bad, but you need to know who's accountable. If subs are used, confirm they're also insured and that the primary contractor's warranty covers their work. Ask who the on-site foreman will be and get their direct contact number.

Pro tip: Ask to meet the crew foreman before signing. The salesperson won't be on your roof — the foreman's experience and communication skills matter more.

7. Do you pull permits and schedule inspections?

Most jurisdictions require a building permit for roof replacement ($100-$500). Contractors who skip permits are cutting corners and exposing you to code violations that surface when you sell the house. A proper job includes a post-installation inspection by your local building department.

Pro tip: Ask to see the permit once it's pulled. You can also call your local building department to verify. If a contractor says your area 'doesn't require permits,' verify that yourself — they may be lying.

8. What warranty do you offer on labor?

Shingle manufacturers warranty the materials (25-50 years typically), but that doesn't cover installation errors — which cause 90% of premature roof failures. A reputable roofer offers 5-10 years on workmanship minimum. Get the warranty in writing with specifics: what's covered, what voids it, and whether it transfers if you sell the house.

Pro tip: A workmanship warranty is only as good as the company behind it. A 25-year labor warranty from a company that's been around for 2 years is meaningless. Weight the warranty by the company's track record.

9. How will you protect my property during the job?

Tear-off creates massive debris — old shingles, nails, flashing. Professional roofers use tarps over landscaping, magnetic nail sweepers on your lawn and driveway, and dumpsters positioned to protect your driveway. They should also cover your AC unit and move vehicles away from the work zone. Nail damage to tires and trampled landscaping are the most common homeowner complaints.

Pro tip: Walk the property with the foreman before AND after the job. Take dated photos of your landscaping, gutters, and siding before work begins.

10. What is your payment schedule?

Never pay more than 10-15% upfront (for materials). A common structure is: 10% deposit, 40% at material delivery, 50% at completion and final inspection. Any contractor demanding full payment upfront or cash-only is a major red flag. Use a credit card if possible — it gives you dispute rights if the work is never completed or defective.

Pro tip: In many states, contractors legally cannot collect more than 10-33% as a deposit. Check your state's contractor regulations before signing.

11. Will you remove the old roof or go over it?

Building codes in most areas allow a maximum of two layers of shingles. Layering over old shingles is cheaper ($1,000-$3,000 less) but hides damage, adds weight to your roof structure, shortens the new roof's life by 20-40%, and may void the shingle manufacturer's warranty. A full tear-off to bare decking is almost always the better investment.

Pro tip: If a roofer recommends going over existing shingles, get a second opinion. The $1,000-$3,000 you save now typically costs $5,000+ in shortened roof life and hidden damage.

12. Can I contact 3 recent customers for references?

Any established roofer should happily provide references from jobs completed in the last 6 months. Call them and ask: Did they finish on time? Was the final price close to the estimate? How was cleanup? Did they honor warranty claims? Drive by the reference homes if they're nearby — you can spot poor workmanship from the street (wavy shingle lines, messy flashing).

Pro tip: Ask references specifically about problems. Every job has hiccups — what matters is how the contractor handled them. A roofer who fixes mistakes quickly is better than one who claims perfection.

Bonus Tip

The Storm Chaser Test

After a major storm, someone will knock on your door offering a 'free inspection.' Legitimate local roofers don't need to canvass neighborhoods. If a roofer approaches you unsolicited, asks you to sign anything on the spot, or offers to 'handle everything with your insurance company,' walk away. File any insurance claim yourself and choose your own contractor.

What to Avoid

  • Never sign a contract on the same day you get the estimate — take 48 hours to compare and verify
  • Avoid contractors who only accept cash or ask for payment before any work begins
  • Don't let a roofer 'supplement' your insurance claim — this often involves inflating damage reports, which is insurance fraud
  • Never hire based on the lowest bid alone — the cheapest roofer is almost never the best value