1. Are you a certified arborist, and is your certification current?
ISA (International Society of Arboriculture) certification requires passing a comprehensive exam, maintaining continuing education credits, and adhering to a code of ethics. It's the baseline professional credential for arborists. Ask for their ISA certification number and verify it at treesaregood.org. Non-certified tree workers may have practical skills, but certification demonstrates both knowledge and accountability.
Pro tip: ISA offers several certification levels. ISA Certified Arborist is the standard credential. ISA Board Certified Master Arborist indicates advanced expertise. Both are verifiable online.
2. What specifically are you recommending and why?
A good arborist explains the reasoning behind every recommendation in terms you can understand. 'This tree needs crown reduction' should be followed by 'because the weight of the extended limbs is creating a failure risk at the attachment point.' If the arborist can't explain why the work is needed in plain language, they may be recommending unnecessary procedures. You're paying for expertise, and expertise includes communication.
Pro tip: Ask: 'What happens if I don't do this work?' A trustworthy arborist will distinguish between urgent safety work, important maintenance, and optional improvements.
3. What pruning standard will you follow?
ANSI A300 is the industry standard for tree pruning. It specifies proper cut locations, maximum branch removal percentages, and prohibited practices (like topping and lion-tailing). Ask whether they follow ANSI A300. Companies that don't know what it is or dismiss it as unnecessary are companies that may damage your trees with improper cuts that invite disease, decay, and structural failure.
Pro tip: ANSI A300 limits branch removal to 25% of the live canopy per session for mature trees. Any arborist proposing to remove more than this should explain the exceptional circumstance that warrants it.
4. How will this work affect the tree's long-term health?
Every cut is a wound the tree must seal. Improper pruning creates wounds that won't close, allowing decay to enter. Over-pruning stresses the tree by removing too much photosynthetic capacity. Ask how the proposed work will affect the tree's health over the next 5-10 years — not just how it will look next week. A professional arborist thinks in decades, not days.
Pro tip: Ask: 'Will this tree need follow-up pruning, and when?' Good pruning programs are phased over 2-3 sessions to avoid over-stressing the tree in a single visit.
5. What equipment will you use, and will you use climbing spikes?
Climbing spikes (spurs) puncture the bark and cambium with every step, creating wounds that invite disease and decay. Spikes are appropriate only for tree removal — never for pruning live trees. If a crew proposes to spike a tree for pruning, they will damage it. Professional arborists use rope-and-saddle climbing or aerial lifts for pruning, reserving spikes exclusively for trees being removed.
Pro tip: Ask directly: 'Will your climbers use spikes on this tree?' If the tree is being pruned (not removed) and the answer is yes, find a different arborist.
6. Do you carry liability insurance and workers' compensation?
Tree work is inherently dangerous. Falling branches, chainsaw work at height, and proximity to power lines create risks for workers and property. Liability insurance covers damage to your property. Workers' compensation covers worker injuries. Both are essential. Ask for a current certificate of insurance and verify it with the carrier. Companies that operate without insurance transfer financial risk to you.
Pro tip: Your homeowner's insurance does not cover damage caused by an uninsured contractor you hired. If their crew drops a limb on your roof and they're uninsured, you're filing a claim on your own policy — and your rates go up.
7. What will you do to protect my property during the work?
Ground protection for lawns, fencing around work zones, rigging plans for branches over structures, and debris containment are all part of professional tree work. Ask specifically: 'How will you protect my driveway, fence, garden beds, and roof from damage during the work?' A blank look or vague 'we're careful' answer means they haven't assessed your property — they're planning to wing it.
Pro tip: Walk the property with the crew leader before work starts and point out what you want protected — irrigation heads, landscape lighting, garden beds. Document it in writing.
8. Can I see examples of similar work you've done?
Before-and-after photos of similar species, similar-sized trees, and similar work scope show you what to expect. An arborist who takes photos of their work takes pride in it. An arborist who can't show examples either doesn't document their work or isn't confident it looks good. Ask for 3-5 examples of the specific type of work proposed — crown reduction, deadwood removal, structural pruning.
Pro tip: Look at the after photos critically. Well-pruned trees maintain their natural form. Poorly pruned trees look lopsided, butchered, or stubbed. Trust your eye — bad pruning looks wrong even to non-experts.
Bonus Tip
Get the plan in writing before any cutting starts
A written scope of work should specify: which trees are included, what type of pruning or treatment each receives, what the finished result should look like, timeline, price, and payment terms. Verbal agreements about tree work are especially dangerous because the work is irreversible. Once a branch is cut, it can't be reattached.
What to Avoid
- Accepting a recommendation to 'top' any tree — topping is the single most harmful pruning practice and is condemned by every professional arboricultural organization.
- Approving work without understanding why it's needed — unnecessary pruning wastes money and stresses trees.
- Choosing the cheapest bid without verifying ISA certification — uncertified tree workers cause the most damage.
- Allowing tree work near power lines without verifying the crew is utility-line certified — contact with power lines is lethal.