1. Are you ISA-certified, and is the certification current?
The International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) certification means the arborist passed an exam on tree biology, pruning science, risk assessment, and safety — and maintains continuing education credits. It is the minimum credential for anyone making cuts on large trees. ISA certification is individual (not company-wide), so ask which person on the crew holds it and whether they will be on-site making cut decisions. A company can be 'ISA-certified' while sending uncertified crews to your property.
Pro tip: Verify current certification at treesaregood.org/findanarborist. Ask for the individual's certification number — if they hesitate, it may be expired or they may be claiming a former employee's credential.
2. What pruning standard do you follow (ANSI A300)?
ANSI A300 is the national pruning standard that defines proper cut types, maximum removal percentages, and prohibited practices (topping, lion-tailing). An arborist who references A300 standards is trained in science-based pruning. One who has never heard of it is making cuts based on personal preference or what looks good from the ground — which often means over-pruning that weakens the tree structurally.
Pro tip: A specific follow-up: 'What percentage of the live canopy will you remove?' ANSI A300 recommends no more than 25% in a single pruning event. Anything over 25% stresses the tree and triggers watersprout response that weakens structure.
3. Will you climb with spikes or use a climbing line system?
Climbing spikes (spurs) puncture bark and cambium with every step, creating wounds that invite disease and decay in the tree. Spikes are appropriate only for removals — never for pruning a tree you intend to keep. Professional arborists prune using climbing line systems (SRT or DdRT) that do not damage the tree. If an arborist plans to spike up your tree for pruning, they are either untrained or prioritizing their own convenience over tree health.
Pro tip: Look at the tree's trunk for old spike wounds (small paired holes going up the trunk). If a previous service used spikes for pruning, those wounds are permanent — factor that into your current arborist evaluation of the tree's health.
4. Do you carry both liability insurance and workers' compensation?
Large-tree pruning is inherently dangerous — falling limbs, chainsaw use at height, and rigging operations all create injury and property damage risk. General liability ($1M-$2M) covers damage to your property. Workers' compensation covers injuries to the crew on your property. Without workers' comp, an injured climber can file a claim against your homeowner's policy. Request a Certificate of Insurance showing both coverages with current dates.
Pro tip: Call the insurance company listed on the certificate to verify the policy is active. Some contractors show certificates from lapsed policies — a 30-second phone call confirms current coverage.
5. Can you walk me through what you plan to cut and why?
A professional arborist should be able to stand under your tree and explain their proposed cuts using specific terminology: 'removing this dead leader,' 'reducing this lateral to a viable branch point,' 'thinning the interior for air circulation.' If they say 'we will trim it up' or 'take some off the top,' they do not have a defined plan. Every cut on a mature tree should have a specific structural or health rationale.
Pro tip: Ask them to identify 3-4 specific cuts they plan to make and explain the reasoning for each. This takes 5 minutes and reveals instantly whether they are applying pruning science or just cutting what seems overgrown.
6. How do you handle branches near power lines or structures?
Branches near power lines require utility notification or utility-line-clearance certified workers (separate from ISA certification). Branches over structures require rigging (rope systems to lower cut sections) rather than dropping them. Ask what rigging equipment they carry and whether they will need a crane for sections over the house. The answer tells you whether they can safely perform the work or whether they will take shortcuts that risk your property.
Pro tip: If any branches are within 10 feet of power lines, call your utility company first. Many utilities will trim in their easement for free, or they must be notified before any contractor works near their lines.
7. What does your written estimate include for cleanup and debris removal?
Large-tree pruning generates significant debris — a single mature oak pruning can fill a full dump trailer. Confirm the estimate includes: removal of all debris from your property, chipping of branches, and removal of chips (or leaving them if you want mulch). Some companies leave a brush pile and call the job done. Others charge extra for hauling if the debris volume exceeds their estimate. Get full cleanup terms in writing.
Pro tip: Ask: 'Is there any circumstance where I would owe more than the quoted price?' This catches hidden charges for excess debris, difficult access, or 'unforeseen' conditions that the arborist should have identified during the quote visit.
8. When was the last time you pruned a tree of this species and size?
Different tree species have different pruning requirements — timing restrictions (oaks should not be pruned during certain months due to oak wilt risk), wound-closure rates, and structural growth patterns. A pruning plan for a mature white oak differs fundamentally from one for a red maple. Ask for specific experience with your tree's species and comparable size. Generic 'we prune everything' answers suggest a one-size-fits-all approach that may not serve your specific tree.
Pro tip: For oaks specifically, ask about pruning timing. Oaks in oak wilt zones should only be pruned during dormant season (November-March). An arborist willing to prune your oak in May either does not know about oak wilt risk or does not care.
Bonus Tip
Request before-and-after photos of their pruning on similar trees
Ask to see photos of trees they have pruned (same species, similar size) showing the tree before and 6-12 months after pruning. Proper pruning looks natural and balanced months later. Over-pruning looks obviously thin or triggers dense watersprout growth along main branches. This is the most revealing evidence of their pruning philosophy.
What to Avoid
- Hiring anyone who offers or suggests topping (cutting the main leader or trunk) — topping is universally condemned by certified arborists and creates dangerous regrowth patterns.
- Choosing a tree service based solely on the lowest bid — cheap pruning often means aggressive over-pruning (fewer cuts = less time = lower cost) that damages tree structure.
- Allowing work during nesting season without a nest check — federal migratory bird laws impose fines for disturbing active nests during work.
- Accepting a verbal quote for large-tree work — written estimates with specific scope prevent scope creep, surprise charges, and disputes about what was agreed.