1. Liberty Home Guard Appliance Guard Covers 9 Key Appliances
This $57/month plan covers refrigerators, garage door openers, and exhaust fans with no age limits on most items. Service fee is $65-$125, lower than AHS's $100-$125. Offers 37 add-ons like pest control for $7-$12 extra monthly.
Pro tip: Pair with Systems Guard for $63/month total home coverage, adding electrical and plumbing without overlapping premiums.
2. American Home Shield ShieldGold Offers $5,000 HVAC Limit
ShieldGold plan starts at $35-$75/month with $100-$125 service fee, covering HVAC up to $5,000, electrical/plumbing to $3,000 each. Annual cap reaches $50,000, exceeding most competitors' $3,000-$6,000 limits. Includes unknown preexisting conditions.
Pro tip: Upgrade to ShieldPlatinum for $2,000-$4,000 per appliance and rust/corrosion coverage, adding $10-$15/month.
3. Choice Home Warranty Total Plan Includes Roof Leaks
$46-$55/month basic plan with $85 service fee covers systems/appliances to $3,000 limit plus limited roof leaks. Add-ons like pools cost under $14.99/month, 25% less than Elite's $15-$20. 24-48 hour response time.
Pro tip: Claim acceptance rate tops 80%, so file within 24 hours of issue for fastest approval.
4. Select Home Warranty Platinum Care Bundles Roof Coverage
$44-$48/month with $75-$100 service fee includes roof leaks in base plan, unlike most requiring $10+ add-ons. Covers 50+ items with $500/appliance, $2,000/system caps. Available in 46 states.
Pro tip: Opt for Platinum over Gold/Bronze for 30% more items at just $5 extra monthly.
5. Elite Home Warranty Comprehensive Plan Boosts Add-Ons
$44.99-$58.99/month, $70 service fee, A+ BBB rating. Covers major appliances/systems with extensive add-ons at $15-$20/month. 48-hour response, higher satisfaction scores than Choice's B rating.
Pro tip: 48-hour guarantee ensures repairs start fast; request color-matched replacements where available.
6. AFC Home Warranty Platinum Includes Plumbing Stoppages
$43.67-$99.08/month across four plans, $75-$125 fee, allows technician choice. Platinum covers microwaves/ice makers with one-day claim window. Silver plan saves 15% on basics vs. comprehensive.
Pro tip: Cancel within 30 days for full refund minus $75 fee; auto-renew saves $5/month.
7. First American Home Warranty Basic Plan Starts Low
$46.67+/month, $85 fee, strong appliance coverage up to $3,500/item. Premier plan adds systems for $10 more monthly. 24/7 online claims in 48 states.
Pro tip: Bundle with real estate for $600-$700/year Platinum, averaging $75 deductible.
8. 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty Provides 65% Appliance Discounts
$39.99+/month, $75 fee, A+ BBB, workmanship guarantee. Add-ons for garage doors/roof leaks at $7/month. Excludes AK/HI, color-matches replacements.
Pro tip: $5/month auto-renew discount stacks with 65% off Whirlpool/GE repairs.
9. Cinch Home Services Combos Backed by 180-Day Guarantee
$34.99-$61.99/month, $100+ fee, covers systems/appliances with 180-day workmanship vs. AHS's 30 days. No state limits on most plans. Top overall rating from 12,000+ reviews.
Pro tip: Report pre-closing issues in one day for home buyer coverage up to $2,000/appliance.
Bonus Tip
Match Plan to Home Age for Max Savings
Homes over 10 years old benefit from AHS's preexisting coverage, saving $1,000+ on HVAC. Newer homes pick Select for roof perks at $44/month. Quote 3 providers to find $10-$20/month variances by ZIP.
What to Avoid
- Ignoring service fees above $100, which add 20-30% to annual costs on frequent claims like plumbing at $300/visit.
- Overlooking state exclusions like AHS skipping AK/HI or 2-10 missing them, leaving 10% of buyers uncovered.
- Skipping add-on costs review; Elite's $15-$20/month extras inflate totals 25% vs. Choice's $14.99 max.
- Choosing based on monthly premium alone; Liberty's $50-$60 hides higher limits worth $2,000+ in payouts.