1. Hiring a painter who doesn't know your local preservation ordinances
Historic districts have specific rules about exterior paint colors, sheen levels, and sometimes even application methods. A painter who doesn't know these rules will choose whatever the homeowner requests — and the preservation board will issue a violation notice after the job is done. The homeowner pays to repaint, not the contractor. Before hiring, ask the painter to name your district's specific requirements. If they can't, they haven't done the homework.
Pro tip: Call your local historic preservation office before soliciting bids. Get the approved color palette and any application restrictions in writing, then include them in the bid request.
2. Allowing power sanding on original wood surfaces
Original wood trim, siding, and window frames on historic homes often have profiles, tooling marks, and dimensional characteristics that cannot be reproduced. Aggressive power sanding removes these details permanently. It also generates lead dust on any pre-1978 surface. Proper historic paint preparation uses chemical strippers, heat plates (not heat guns), and hand scraping to remove failing paint while preserving the wood profile underneath.
Pro tip: Ask the painter: 'How do you remove failing paint from original wood trim?' If the answer involves a belt sander or aggressive orbital sanding, that painter is wrong for this job.
3. Skipping a lead paint assessment on a pre-1978 home
Nearly every home built before 1978 in a historic district has lead paint. EPA RRP rules require certified contractors and specific containment protocols when disturbing lead paint. Beyond the legal requirement, historic homes often have thick lead paint buildup in window channels and door frames that generates invisible but dangerous dust when scraped. Skipping the assessment doesn't save money — it creates health liability and potential EPA fines up to $37,500 per day.
Pro tip: Ask the painter for both their firm's EPA RRP certification and the individual worker certifications. The firm certification alone is not sufficient.
4. Choosing modern acrylic paint for surfaces that need oil-based
Many original historic surfaces were painted with oil-based paint. Applying latex or acrylic directly over old oil-based paint without proper prep causes adhesion failure — the new paint peels in sheets within 1–3 years. Some historic preservation boards also require oil-based or alkyd finishes on specific elements to maintain authentic appearance and moisture-management properties. A knowledgeable historic painter tests existing paint chemistry before selecting products.
Pro tip: The acetone test: rub a cotton ball soaked in acetone on the existing paint. If paint comes off on the cotton, it's latex/acrylic. If it doesn't, it's oil-based and requires bonding primer before topcoating.
5. Not getting a color approval from the preservation board before painting
Many historic districts require pre-approval of exterior color schemes. Painting first and seeking approval after is a gamble that rarely pays off. If the board rejects your color, you pay for a full repaint — including the contractor's remobilization fee. The approval process typically takes 2–4 weeks, so build it into your project timeline.
Pro tip: Submit large painted samples on boards to the preservation committee, not just paint chips. Colors look dramatically different on a 4x4 board than on a 1-inch chip.
6. Ignoring substrate repairs before repainting
Historic homes often have deteriorated wood, crumbling masonry mortar, and failing caulk joints that must be repaired before paint goes on. Painting over rotted wood or cracked mortar seals moisture in and accelerates decay. A quality historic painter includes substrate repair in their scope — or explicitly calls out what a carpenter or mason needs to fix before painting begins. A cheap bid that skips repair is a bid for paint failure.
Pro tip: Probe all wood surfaces with an awl before the painter begins. Soft, spongy wood needs epoxy consolidation or replacement — not just another coat of paint.
Bonus Tip
Photograph every original detail before work begins
Historic homes have architectural details — rosettes, dentil molding, corner boards, decorative brackets — that can be damaged or simplified during painting. Photograph every elevation and every detail element before work starts. If something gets damaged or simplified, your photos are the restoration reference and the basis for any damage claim.
What to Avoid
- Hiring the lowest bidder without verifying historic painting experience — general painters rarely understand preservation requirements or period-appropriate techniques.
- Pressure washing a historic home's exterior without testing a small area first — high pressure can drive water behind siding, erode soft mortar, and damage wood grain.
- Using modern caulk colors and products on historic trim — silicone caulk looks wrong on period details and can stain surrounding wood.
- Assuming your homeowner's insurance covers preservation board fines — it typically does not, and fines for unauthorized color changes can reach $500/day.